MODERNISM AS A RUIN
An Archaeology of the Present

  • 2009_1_Ruine_foyer_01 Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_grHalle_01_voerman Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_grHalle_09_Smithson Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_grHalle_10_gaillard Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_grhalle_11_deRijkedeRooij Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_klHalle_02_genzken_graham Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_klHalle_04_gabellone Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_seitenhalle_01_mattaclark Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
  • 2009_1_Ruine_seitenhalle_12_gaillard Exhibition view: Modernism as a Ruin. An Archeology of the Present, Generali Foundation, Photo: © Raimo Rumpler
    From 06/19 to 09/20/2009
    Curator: Sabine Folie
    Assistant Curator: Ilse Lafer

    Works by Yona Friedman, Giuseppe Gabellone, Cyprien Gaillard, Isa Genzken, Dan Graham, Gordon Matta-Clark, Florian Pumhösl, Jeroen de Rijke / Willem de Rooij, Robert Smithson, Rob Voerman, Stephen Willats.

    The exhibition set its sights on modernity’s design for a more humane and contemporary society since the early twentieth century: a design for new forms of living and new cityscapes. What has happened to this utopia?

    The architecture and design concepts by the artists represented in the exhibition contemplated "models" of utopian, pure design in their state of deterioration. Sometimes preserving moments of the crystalline, they were riddled with decay, entropy, ruin, and "rust" (Smithson), yet found nourishment from the idea of the bricolage, the implementation "of that which is there," from the concept of recycling, so to speak. With that, they formulated final day stages, testing survival on the remnants of a demised civilization. These remnants were understood as the last resources. On the other hand, these approaches thus took up a practically utopian thought of "sustainability," the idea of a better society, born of the spirit of dystopia.

    When desolation, neglect, and the degeneration to slums as bleak and relentless final evidence of an exploitative, brutalized society of competition, profit, and fanaticism have caused the utopia of a humane, enlightened society to collapse, then humility is called for in order to make something from the void with whatever means remain after the catastrophe. These dystopias were constructed from the hackneyed ideas of a thousand-year old human history, of the resonance and reflected memory of utopian design and architecture, in view of which an awareness ought to be generated that available resources are limited and a redefinition of the new, of progress is called for.

    It was no coincidence that the genealogy of the exhibition’s artists began in the 1970s, a time in which the shimmer of pop and minimal art began to crumble and the post-industrial era made visible the limits of growth. Key figures here are Robert Smithson and Gordon Matta-Clark, who analyzed their present day in their own special way, critically and emphatically, also prophetically. Taking the concrete run-down or repressed reality of the cities’ wastelands as well as the monuments of industrial archeology and the suburbs as their starting-point, they aimed at detecting the entropic state of the present, or possibly even invoking it. Despite the attraction of the shimmering and reflecting surfaces of 1930s Modernism that Smithson described in an equally ecstatic and ambivalent way in his legendary essay "Ultramoderne," Smithson and Matta-Clark became deeply involved in the entropic ruinous state as proof of fleetingness. Nonetheless, Smithson also described the state of postindustrial architecture with the concept of reversed ruins, buildings which "rise into ruin before they are built This negative dialectic becomes clear as "undoing" in Smithson’s Partially Buried Woodshed and Matta-Clark’s dissecting interventions—affirmation through deconstruction. Entropic areas, places of transfer and dissolution, such as the garbage dumps favored in Matta-Clark’s Fire Child, become sites of alchemist action: the purifying powers of fire serve to create a site of non-alienated action in a practically primordial ritual within the urban wastelands—to gain something new from garbage—rather than to dispose of undesirable garbage. Allegorically, the Garbage Wall functions as a prototype or first building block of a structure; later the fire serves to grill a pig finally distributed to all present.

    What was still a site of involved action here, the site of an "art of practice" of the urban flaneur, who is a critically observing participant, is perceived from afar, with detachment in Bantar Gebang by Jeroen de Rijke / Willem de Rooij: people who have set up a neighborhood on a garbage dump are perceived as others by another. Rob Voerman, on the contrary, uses parts of garbage to erect his hybrid dwellings.

    When Isa Genzken and Dan Graham in Chicago Drive or Private "Public" Space: The Corporate Atrium Garden take up the promise of Modernism’s utopian architecture, that is, the Ultramoderne, in cruises through an iridescent, sparkling, crystalline, and simultaneously ethereally cold, gleaming Chicago of skyscrapers, or pursue the attempts to bring back nature manifest in corporate buildings—where talk is thus of the beauty of the architectural, its brittleness and fleetingness and false appearances likewise emerge, allegorically presented in the intro to Chicago Drive with the journey past the idyllic eternal calm of a cemetery, a special type of suburb of the dead.

    The obverse of these representative buildings is to be found in the outskirts and their tower blocks, which Stephen Willats and Cyprien Gaillard both investigate in their own way. Gaillard accepts the dilapidated beauty of the neighborhoods degenerated to ruins and social problem zones, which as in the case of Pruitt-Igoe, Scampìa, or the Parisian Banlieues are laid in ashes in baroque fireworks. Since the 1960s, Willats has carried out systemic studies with the inhabitants of blocks of flats on the outskirts, presenting the results in diagrammatic photomontages. The inherent shady side of the "concrete blocks" comes up, but is not demonized per se; he rather focuses on the changed lifestyle and the failure of politics.

    In the 1970s, the crisis of capitalism clearly manifested itself in the downfall of some cities, in particular, New York. This made it deducible what it means when resources become ever scarcer and social services cease, entire neighborhoods go to ruin, and the economy is controlled by combines. Yona Friedman raised his voice as an architect already at an early stage and, contrary to what one would expect, referred to the second half of the twentieth century as a "poor" century, in which everyone was now urged to share resources. Ecological and social utopian thoughts, as developed by Friedman and Matta-Clark, who was trained as an architect, have lost nothing of their explosiveness. Thus, quite a few present-day artists deliberately refer to "forerunners" from the 1970s; but there is also an indirect thread of thought figures orbiting Modernism’s themes and their results which carry through until today and which we saw reflected in the exhibition in works by Rob Voerman, Jeroen de Rijke / Willem de Rooij, Giuseppe Gabellone, Florian Pumhösl, Gyprien Gaillard, and Stephen Willats. An arc spanned from concepts such as the crystalline, entropy, ruins, and bricolage, which in reaction to Formalism have been increasingly theorized in Postmodernism, to the works shown in the exhibition.

    Second venue: Kunstmuseum Liechtenstein from October 2, 2009 to January 17, 2010.